self portrait and value value value
Tuesday, November 25th, 2008I thank you all for your comments (most came through email and are not on the site). The opinions were mixed about equally between the photo and the quilt. I decided that what I didn’t like about the quilt was that it got puffy with the batting inside, so I spent three hours pulling out every single stitch so that I could redo it without batting. (Yes, I am crazy!).
Having done that this morning (while baking for thanksgiving) I still didn’t like it. It just didn’t look like me. The jaw and chin didn’t look right. The answer, as it almost always is–VALUE. Although there was a difference in value between the fabrics I used, their relation to each other was wrong. So I started again (I told you I am crazy).
Look at this photo and you will see the problem. The finished (first) quilt on the right, the photo in the center, and the new piece (in work) on the left. Even without the eyes, the new one looks more like me than the finished one.
Looking at the finished one, there is a difference in the values of the skin tones and shadows but not enough. So even though the pieces are the right shape, the chin and jaw don’t show up enough. The face was redone using six different values, #1 and #2 being fairly close to each other (in fact, #1 is the back of #2) and then a bigger jump in value to #3. That means that the jaw and chin are more well defined.
On the other hand, the lips were too dark, lightening them looks more natural. And the hair in the first quilt is too contrasty–my real hair has only subtle highlights.
The point? Value is often more important than color in creating the image. Just look at these portraits I did a while back in completely non-naturalistic colors:
So that is my thought on value and their importance in the final product. I hope to have this finished by tomorrow, and will post the finished quilt for your opinions again.
Have a wonderful thanksgiving. Thank you for supporting my little blog!


























